Why ESG Investing Might Never Recover
Kanebridge News
    HOUSE MEDIAN ASKING PRICES AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney $1,634,647 (-0.13%)       Melbourne $1,014,731 (+0.07%)       Brisbane $1,039,137 (-0.36%)       Adelaide $946,102 (+1.11%)       Perth $923,113 (+0.00%)       Hobart $749,205 (-0.26%)       Darwin $765,670 (+0.77%)       Canberra $969,848 (-0.24%)       National $1,071,435 (+0.00%)                UNIT MEDIAN ASKING PRICES AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney $758,834 (-0.41%)       Melbourne $487,148 (-0.17%)       Brisbane $653,985 (-0.35%)       Adelaide $489,117 (+0.05%)       Perth $515,967 (+2.54%)       Hobart $536,451 (-0.17%)       Darwin $393,381 (-0.30%)       Canberra $502,832 (-0.14%)       National $562,892 (-0.01%)                HOUSES FOR SALE AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney 8,884 (+55)       Melbourne 12,619 (-146)       Brisbane 7,202 (+7)       Adelaide 2,094 (-28)       Perth 7,246 (-121)       Hobart 1,177 (-5)       Darwin 180 (-6)       Canberra 935 (0)       National 40,337 (-244)                UNITS FOR SALE AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney 7,552 (-28)       Melbourne 7,416 (-124)       Brisbane 1,405 (-19)       Adelaide 335 (-10)       Perth 1,635 (-17)       Hobart 211 (-4)       Darwin 270 (-2)       Canberra 1,088 (-3)       National 19,912 (-207)                HOUSE MEDIAN ASKING RENTS AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney $790 ($0)       Melbourne $590 ($0)       Brisbane $650 ($0)       Adelaide $620 ($0)       Perth $680 (+$3)       Hobart $550 ($0)       Darwin $780 (-$10)       Canberra $690 (+$10)       National $678 (-$)                UNIT MEDIAN ASKING RENTS AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney $750 ($0)       Melbourne $580 (+$5)       Brisbane $650 ($0)       Adelaide $500 ($0)       Perth $650 ($0)       Hobart $463 (+$13)       Darwin $590 ($0)       Canberra $580 ($0)       National $607 (+$1)                HOUSES FOR RENT AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney 6,170 (+108)       Melbourne 7,721 (+258)       Brisbane 4,198 (+175)       Adelaide 1,437 (+53)       Perth 2,145 (+88)       Hobart 223 (+20)       Darwin 138 (+3)       Canberra 618 (+18)       National 22,650 (+723)                UNITS FOR RENT AND WEEKLY CHANGE     Sydney 10,392 (+146)       Melbourne 7,383 (+273)       Brisbane 2,399 (+176)       Adelaide 348 (+13)       Perth 521 (+51)       Hobart 92 (+16)       Darwin 247 (+4)       Canberra 679 (+19)       National 22,061 (+698)                HOUSE ANNUAL GROSS YIELDS AND TREND       Sydney 2.51% (↑)        Melbourne 3.02% (↓)     Brisbane 3.25% (↑)        Adelaide 3.41% (↓)     Perth 3.83% (↑)      Hobart 3.82% (↑)        Darwin 5.30% (↓)     Canberra 3.70% (↑)        National 3.29% (↓)            UNIT ANNUAL GROSS YIELDS AND TREND       Sydney 5.14% (↑)      Melbourne 6.19% (↑)      Brisbane 5.17% (↑)        Adelaide 5.32% (↓)       Perth 6.55% (↓)     Hobart 4.48% (↑)      Darwin 7.80% (↑)      Canberra 6.00% (↑)      National 5.61% (↑)             HOUSE RENTAL VACANCY RATES AND TREND       Sydney 2.0% (↑)      Melbourne 1.9% (↑)      Brisbane 1.4% (↑)      Adelaide 1.3% (↑)      Perth 1.2% (↑)      Hobart 1.0% (↑)      Darwin 1.6% (↑)      Canberra 2.7% (↑)      National 1.7% (↑)             UNIT RENTAL VACANCY RATES AND TREND       Sydney 2.4% (↑)      Melbourne 3.8% (↑)      Brisbane 2.0% (↑)      Adelaide 1.1% (↑)      Perth 0.9% (↑)      Hobart 1.4% (↑)      Darwin 2.8% (↑)      Canberra 2.9% (↑)      National 2.2% (↑)             AVERAGE DAYS TO SELL HOUSES AND TREND       Sydney 33.7 (↑)      Melbourne 32.8 (↑)      Brisbane 33.8 (↑)      Adelaide 27.5 (↑)      Perth 38.4 (↑)      Hobart 31.5 (↑)      Darwin 47.8 (↑)      Canberra 34.3 (↑)      National 35.0 (↑)             AVERAGE DAYS TO SELL UNITS AND TREND       Sydney 36.1 (↑)      Melbourne 33.5 (↑)      Brisbane 33.1 (↑)      Adelaide 26.5 (↑)      Perth 40.9 (↑)      Hobart 35.9 (↑)        Darwin 33.3 (↓)     Canberra 41.3 (↑)      National 35.1 (↑)            
Share Button

Why ESG Investing Might Never Recover

The appeal of the moniker is waning, probably because it is trying to serve too many interests at once

By JON SINDREU
Tue, Mar 26, 2024 7:00amGrey Clock 4 min

The ESG brand probably has its best days behind it.

Following a three-year craze for investment products focused on environmental, social and corporate-governance concerns, the percentage of newly created funds in the U.S. and Europe with ESG in their name has fallen from a peak of 8.3% to just 3.3%, according to an analysis of quarterly data by Morningstar Direct.

Likewise, online searches for “ESG investing” have plummeted back to mid-2019 levels, according to Google Trends. Mentions of the term in company analyst calls have dropped 59% from their quarterly peak in 2022, FactSet data suggest.

One explanation is the collapse of the clean-energy stocks most readily associated with the ESG movement. Flagging growth in electric-vehicle sales has hit sector behemoth Tesla . The S&P Global Clean Energy index, which lists solar-panel maker First Solar and Danish wind-turbine giant Vestas among its top constituents, has lost 31% since the start of 2023 as renewable-energy projects have been shelved. That compares with returns of 27% for global stocks.

The rise of ESG investing between 2019 and 2022 coincided with a surge in clean-tech valuations, and now the reverse is happening. Investors have pulled $2.2 billion from funds dedicated to decarbonisation since the start of the year, according to EPFR, and the outflows are getting larger every week.

There is a risk that ESG was an investment fad rather than a financial revolution extending across all industries.

The term was the product of an uneasy three-way alliance. On one side were ethically driven investors, who are particularly widespread in Scandinavia and include pension funds, universities and religious organisations united in wanting to shun contentious firms. On another were institutions such as the United Nations that aimed to channel money to industries that benefit society. Finally, there were investors who wanted to profit from the green revolution.

Asset managers jumped at the chance to cater to all three simultaneously. ESG allowed them to differentiate their products, revitalise the case for active management and, at a time of declining fees, charge more for stock screens that often lead to only small changes in allocations . Among U.S. equity funds, ESG strategies have an asset-weighted average fee of 0.52%, compared with 0.33% overall, Morningstar Direct data shows.

But the confusion of motivations made for contradictions and a lot of doublespeak. Neither ethical objectives nor bets on decarbonisation square logically with fund managers’ claims that ESG is a broad path to higher, safer returns.

Yes, an ESG focus can help active managers account for risks such as a regulatory backlash or governance blow up, which in some cases might be highlighted by new company disclosures. This month the European Union cleared the way toward requiring firms to better report and address sustainability impacts.

However, the assumption that integrating ESG criteria into their screening will lead to better stock picking seems flawed . The very popularity of ESG makes it unlikely that the market is under appreciating the risks. The rush of money into firms like Vestas, whose stock hit a price-to-earnings ratio of 534 in 2022, illustrates the risk that shares with high sustainability scores can get too expensive, leading to lower returns.

Ethical investors might be fine with this, but that just shifts the focus to what counts as ethical. Tellingly, interest in ESG has dropped more in the U.S., where the politicisation of EVs and culture wars surrounding Bud Light beer show how easily corporations can become ideological battlegrounds.

ESG ratings aren’t much help in navigating these issues. Different providers give wildly different scores to the same companies, even within the specific “E,” “S” and “G” factors, according to a February paper by the Leibniz Institute SAFE. Researchers also found that environmental concerns tend to explain most of the overall score.

This is another hint that the ultimate driver of the pandemic-era ESG craze might have been a hunger for thematic investment. It has since found better sources of sustenance, as demonstrated by the breakneck growth of firms such as Global X, which is delivering increasingly granular offerings such as tracker funds for electric batteries, cloud computing and ageing populations.

Buyers of these products can be fickle and jump to the next theme—often too quickly for their own good, a Morningstar analysis showed last November. It is possible that the overly generic ESG brand will never recover its appeal, with the different parts of it eventually rebranded to suit their specific client bases. BlackRock , the world’s largest asset manager, has already dropped it and is now emphasising transition themes over ethical stewardship of companies.

Sustainable investing isn’t going anywhere. But a broad tent covering too many interests serves none of them well.



MOST POPULAR
11 ACRES ROAD, KELLYVILLE, NSW

This stylish family home combines a classic palette and finishes with a flexible floorplan

35 North Street Windsor

Just 55 minutes from Sydney, make this your creative getaway located in the majestic Hawkesbury region.

Related Stories
Money
Israel Defies Expectations With Surge in Tech Funding Despite War
By Carrie Keller-Lynn 14/01/2025
Money
FAMILY MATTERS IN THE GREAT WEALTH TRANSFER
By Emma Koehn 14/01/2025
Money
Stock Futures Are Little Changed Ahead of Jobs Data
By JANET H. CHO 06/01/2025
Israel Defies Expectations With Surge in Tech Funding Despite War

The 28% increase buoyed the country as it battled on several fronts but investment remains down from 2021

By Carrie Keller-Lynn
Tue, Jan 14, 2025 3 min

As the war against Hamas dragged into 2024, there were worries here that investment would dry up in Israel’s globally important technology sector, as much of the world became angry against the casualties in Gaza and recoiled at the unstable security situation.

In fact, a new survey found investment into Israeli technology startups grew 28% last year to $10.6 billion. The influx buoyed Israel’s economy and helped it maintain a war footing on several battlefronts.

The increase marks a turnaround for Israeli startups, which had experienced a decline in investments in 2023 to $8.3 billion, a drop blamed in part on an effort to overhaul the country’s judicial system and the initial shock of the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023 attack.

Tech investment in Israel remains depressed from years past. It is still just a third of the almost $30 billion in private investments raised in 2021, a peak after which Israel followed the U.S. into a funding market downturn.

Any increase in Israeli technology investment defied expectations though. The sector is responsible for 20% of Israel’s gross domestic product and about 10% of employment. It contributed directly to 2.2% of GDP growth in the first three quarters of the year, according to Startup Nation Central—without which Israel would have been on a negative growth trend, it said.

“If you asked me a year before if I expected those numbers, I wouldn’t have,” said Avi Hasson, head of Startup Nation Central, the Tel Aviv-based nonprofit that tracks tech investments and released the investment survey.

Israel’s tech sector is among the world’s largest technology hubs, especially for startups. It has remained one of the most stable parts of the Israeli economy during the 15-month long war, which has taxed the economy and slashed expectations for growth to a mere 0.5% in 2024.

Industry investors and analysts say the war stifled what could have been even stronger growth. The survey didn’t break out how much of 2024’s investment came from foreign sources and local funders.

“We have an extremely innovative and dynamic high tech sector which is still holding on,” said Karnit Flug, a former governor of the Bank of Israel and now a senior fellow at the Jerusalem-based Israel Democracy Institute, a think tank. “It has recovered somewhat since the start of the war, but not as much as one would hope.”

At the war’s outset, tens of thousands of Israel’s nearly 400,000 tech employees were called into reserve service and companies scrambled to realign operations as rockets from Gaza and Lebanon pounded the country. Even as operations normalized, foreign airlines overwhelmingly cut service to Israel, spooking investors and making it harder for Israelis to reach their customers abroad.

An explosion in negative global sentiment toward Israel introduced a new form of risk in doing business with Israeli companies. Global ratings firms lowered Israel’s credit rating over uncertainty caused by the war.

Israel’s government flooded money into the economy to stabilize it shortly after war broke out in October 2023. That expansionary fiscal policy, economists say, stemmed what was an initial economic contraction in the war’s first quarter and helped Israel regain its footing, but is now resulting in expected tax increases to foot the bill.

The 2024 boost was led by investments into Israeli cybersecurity companies, which captured about 40% of all private capital raised, despite representing only 7% of Israeli tech companies. Many of Israel’s tech workers have served in advanced military-technology units, where they can gain experience building products. Israeli tech products are sometimes tested on the battlefield. These factors have led to its cybersecurity companies being dominant in the global market, industry experts said.

The number of Israeli defense-tech companies active throughout 2024 doubled, although they contributed to a much smaller percentage of the overall growth in investments. This included some startups which pivoted to the area amid a surge in global demand spurred by the war in Ukraine and at home in Israel. Funding raised by Israeli defense-tech companies grew to $165 million in 2024, from $19 million the previous year.

“The fact that things are literally battlefield proven, and both the understanding of the customer as well as the ability to put it into use and to accelerate the progress of those technologies, is something that is unique to Israel,” said Hasson.

MOST POPULAR
11 ACRES ROAD, KELLYVILLE, NSW

This stylish family home combines a classic palette and finishes with a flexible floorplan

35 North Street Windsor

Just 55 minutes from Sydney, make this your creative getaway located in the majestic Hawkesbury region.

Related Stories
Money
How Australian spending patterns are changing
By KANEBRIDGE NEWS 16/12/2024
Lifestyle
Swarovski: The Christmas tradition to last a lifetime
By Robyn Willis 05/12/2024
Lifestyle
Skechers Went After the Customers Nike Didn’t. It Paid Off.
By INTI PACHECO 13/01/2025
0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop