HIGH-RISE APARTMENTS VS HOUSES: WHICH INVESTMENT COMES OUT ON TOP?
Kanebridge News
Share Button

HIGH-RISE APARTMENTS VS HOUSES: WHICH INVESTMENT COMES OUT ON TOP?

As Australia accelerates apartment construction, investors face a critical decision between high-rise living and land-backed homes.

By Nina Hendy
Fri, Feb 20, 2026 10:41amGrey Clock 3 min

Australia’s housing shortage has long positioned real estate as a cornerstone of wealth creation. But as governments push to deliver 1.2 million new homes, many of them high-rise apartments, investors are increasingly weighing whether vertical living offers the same long-term returns as traditional houses.

While apartments offer lower entry prices and strong rental demand in key locations, critics warn that strata costs, oversupply and lack of land ownership can undermine long-term capital growth.

LOCATION AND LIFESTYLE DRIVE DEMAND

Company RE chief executive Marcus Buskey says thoughtfully designed high-rise developments in lifestyle precincts can deliver strong returns, particularly in premium coastal markets.

Demand remains robust across the Gold Coast and inner-city Brisbane, driven by downsizers, professionals and interstate buyers seeking convenience and lifestyle.

“Apartments in premium Gold Coast areas like Mermaid Beach, Broadbeach and Burleigh Heads have consistently demonstrated capital growth, driven by limited availability, desirability of location and ongoing demand from lifestyle-focused buyers,” Buskey says.

He adds that quality, exclusivity, views and proximity to amenities remain critical factors influencing performance.

MELBOURNE MARKET SHOWS MIXED SIGNALS

Melbourne project marketing specialist Jon Ellis, founder of The Move, says apartments continue to dominate transactions, accounting for 360 of his last 400 sales.

However, he warns not all developments perform equally.

“Some lower-grade apartments in Melbourne may never go back up to the sales price they were achieving a few years ago,” Ellis says.

He notes that construction costs have risen sharply, making it harder to deliver strong investment yields. Yet demand remains strong for well-executed developments.

“Investors purchasing an apartment for $600,000 need to get about $600 a week in rent. If you can get that right and prove it, demand for apartments certainly outstrips residential houses.”

THE LAND FACTOR REMAINS CRITICAL

Like all investment opportunities, others favour a freestanding home over a high-rise apartment.

“In my opinion, the only people who make money from high-rise apartments are the developers who build and sell them,” buyers’ agent Gianni Musumeci says.

For this reason, the Sydneysider steers investors away from high-rise apartments. “While they may appear to be an appealing investment on the surface with attractive guarantees, modern designs and convenient locations at somewhat lower entry points, high-rise apartments are, in my view, rarely a good investment,” Musumeci, of  Leverage Property Advisers, says.

“This is especially the case when compared to standard residential homes in suburban markets, primarily due to the overwhelmingly high supply of apartments, the high level of cash flow expenses, the number of defects commonly found in high-rise buildings and the cost to remediate them, as well as the lack of land ownership, which is the primary driver of capital growth.”

“Economics 101 tells us that capital growth is achieved when diminishing supply meets increasing demand. The issue with high-rise apartments is that they’re typically built in areas with overwhelming supply, and often, that supply exceeds demand,” he says.

“These developments are usually located around major transport hubs, and as a result, if you’re looking to buy in one of these areas, you’re competing with dozens or even hundreds of similar listings.”

“Apartments are far easier to mass produce because the only restriction is how high you can build. You can’t expect strong growth in a market that’s saturated. In contrast, standalone residential homes are limited by land availability,” Musumeci says.

WEALTH CREATOR FAVOURS FREEHOLD PROPERTY

Entrepreneur and investor Scott O’Neill, who has amassed a combined net worth of $252 million with his wife Mina, says his personal experience has reinforced the benefits of freehold ownership.

He owned a high-rise apartment early in his investing journey but sold it after two years.

“The yields can vary significantly, ranging from four to seven per cent, but that’s before accounting for sinking funds and strata fees. Your net returns often drop to between one and two per cent,” O’Neill says.

He says oversupply and rising strata costs can further weaken performance.

“Most long-term property owners end up selling high-rise apartments in favour of freehold properties.”

INVESTMENT DECISION DEPENDS ON STRATEGY

Despite the risks, apartments can still deliver strong results when chosen carefully.

Experts agree that location, developer quality, supply levels and long-term demand are critical factors.

While houses continue to offer superior land value and long-term growth potential, apartments can provide attractive yields and accessibility for investors seeking exposure to high-demand urban markets.

Ultimately, the right investment depends on an investor’s strategy, time horizon and appetite for risk.



MOST POPULAR

Dutch studio Vripack took cues from a Shirley Temple song for Lollipop, a 37.4-metre Moonen superyacht built for long-range cruising.

A Sydney couple has paid $15.5 million for the Grand Penthouse at Marquee’s $285 million La Belle Residences beachfront development which is nearing completion at Palm Beach, eclipsing the record for an off-the-plan apartment sale on the southern Gold Coast. The sprawling single level 640 sqm beachfront residence, with sweeping views of the Gold Coast …

Related Stories
Property
Sydney renters have more choice as Melbourne vacancies reach 2 per cent
By Ruba Jaajaa 18/11/2026
Property
Noosa beachfront penthouse sells for a record $21.5 million
By Ruba Jaajaa 18/11/2026
Property
Homes are taking longer to sell as Australia’s downturn deepens
By Ruba Jaajaa 18/11/2026
Sydney renters have more choice as Melbourne vacancies reach 2 per cent
By Ruba Jaajaa
Wed, Nov 18, 2026 2 min

Sydney had roughly 4,300 more vacant rentals in October than it did a year earlier, giving tenants a wider pool of properties to inspect. SQM Research counted 13,872 vacancies in the city, up about 45 per cent on October 2025. The vacancy rate held at 1.8 per cent, compared with 1.3 per cent a year earlier.

Melbourne’s vacancy rate rose to 2 per cent, the highest of any capital, with 10,833 properties available. Together, Sydney and Melbourne accounted for more than half the 44,275 vacancies SQM recorded nationally. The national rate edged up to 1.5 per cent, from 1.4 per cent in September and 1.2 per cent a year earlier. SQM’s measure counts online rental listings that have been advertised for at least three weeks.

That three-week threshold matters. A rental let quickly can come and go without entering the count. A bigger pool of listings that have been advertised for at least three weeks suggests more properties are taking longer to lease. SQM noted that Melbourne’s rise in vacancies came as asking rents softened across houses and units during spring, when rents would usually pick up.

Sydney’s house and unit rents are moving in different directions

Sydney unit asking rents fell 0.7 per cent over the 30 days to 12 November, to about $744 a week. House asking rents rose 1.6 per cent to about $1,175. In Melbourne, both fell for a second consecutive month, with units down 1.6 per cent and houses down 0.4 per cent. Melbourne’s combined asking rent was still 5.7 per cent higher than a year earlier.

The Sydney figures put the weekly gap between house and unit asking rents at about $431. The averages cover different properties across the city, but the size of the gap helps explain why a household looking for an extra bedroom or outdoor space may experience a tighter market than someone looking for a unit.

Smaller capitals are still tight

Perth and Adelaide both recorded vacancy rates of 0.6 per cent, while Hobart had the lowest capital-city rate at 0.4 per cent. Brisbane moved up to 1 per cent, the same as a year earlier, and its combined asking rents were still 7.1 per cent higher over the year. Canberra, at 1.9 per cent, was closer to Melbourne and Sydney on availability. Darwin recorded a monthly fall in advertised rents, yet annual growth there was still 11.8 per cent.

A separate Cotality review puts the recent easing in perspective. Its national series recorded rental growth of 0.5 per cent in the September quarter, down from 1.6 per cent in June and 2.1 per cent in March. Even after that slowdown, Cotality estimated national unit rents were $208 a week higher than five years earlier, while house rents had risen $195 a week.

On SQM’s measure, national advertised rents were still 6.4 per cent higher than a year ago. The clearest signs of relief are in Melbourne and in Sydney’s apartment market, where asking rents have eased as more rentals have become available. For renters looking for a detached house in Sydney, the latest figures still point to rising asking prices.

MOST POPULAR

MAISON de SABRÉ’s new Spring Harvest Collection turns everyday produce into collectible leather charms and introduces fresh silhouettes in its cult Bucket bag family.

Victorian auction buyers will soon receive a piece of information that has traditionally been withheld until bidding reaches it: the vendor’s reserve price. Under new property-sale and underquoting laws, agents must publish the agreed reserve at least seven days before an auction or fixed-date sale. Most changes begin on 1 October 2026 and apply to …

Related Stories
Property
ABS building approvals June 2026: apartment approvals up 13%, Housing Accord shortfall widens
By Staff Writer 03/08/2026
Money
The Year’s Hottest Crypto Trade Is Crumbling
By GREGORY ZUCKERMAN AND VICKY GE HUANG 10/11/2025
Property of the Week
Kanebridge Property of the Week: Earlswood brings two eras together in Randwick
By Ruba Jaajaa 30/09/2026
0
Your Cart
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop